NYX Butter Gloss Review:- If you’ve spent any time on beauty TikTok or YouTube, you’ve seen it: the iconic tube of NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss. Touted as a drugstore dupe for high-end lip glosses, it’s built a legendary status for its non-sticky shine and yummy shades. But does it live up to the hype? At Be Glam Girl, we believe in real, tested reviews. We put this cult-favorite gloss through its paces to give you the honest scoop on its formula, wear, and the must-have shades you need to try.
First Impressions: What Is NYX Butter Gloss?
The moment you swipe on NYX Butter Gloss, you understand the name. The texture is distinctly buttery-soft and creamy, gliding over the lips without any tugging. Unlike many glosses that feel like a sticky film, this one feels comfortably lightweight and hydrating, thanks to ingredients like shea butter and vitamin E.
The signature sweet, vanilla-cake scent is noticeable but pleasant and not overpowering. It comes in a straightforward squeeze tube with a standard doe-foot applicator, making it easy to control the amount of product. For the price, the packaging feels durable and practical—no fuss, just function.
In-Depth Review: Testing the Claims
We wore multiple shades for a full week to test the key claims.
-
Shine & Pigmentation: ★★★★☆
The shine is beautiful—a juicy, glass-like finish that catches the light perfectly. The pigmentation varies wonderfully by shade. The nudes and pinks (like Tiramisu or Angel Food Cake) offer a sheer, buildable wash of color, while the berries and mauves (like Red Velvet or Praline) deliver surprisingly rich, opaque color in one swipe. -
Comfort & Wear: ★★★★☆
This is where the Butter Gloss truly shines. It feels like a lip balm, not a glue. There’s zero tackiness or uncomfortable pulling. However, as a creamy gloss, its longevity is what you’d expect: it lasts well through about 2-3 hours of light activity and drinking, but will need reapplication after a meal. It fades evenly without leaving a patchy residue. -
Value for Money: ★★★★★
This is an undeniable win. For a price that’s a fraction of many high-end glosses, you get a high-quality product with a fantastic shade range. It’s a low-risk way to experiment with color and finish.
Top 5 NYX Butter Gloss Shades You Need to Try
With dozens of shades, it can be overwhelming to choose. Here are our top 5 curated picks for different looks and skin tones.
-
Angel Food Cake: The Perfect Nude. This is a cult-favorite for a reason. A warm, peachy beige that gives a “my lips but better” shine. It flatters light to medium skin tones beautifully and is the ideal everyday shade.
-
Praline: The Sophisticated Mauve. A deeper, rosy-mauve that adds definition and a polished pop of color. It’s stunning on medium to deep skin tones and works equally well for day or night.
-
Cinnamon Roll: The Warm Brown. A rich, terracotta brown that’s perfect for the ’90s lip trend. It adds major warmth and depth, especially gorgeous on olive and deep complexions.
-
Tiramisu: The Universal Pink. A soft, cool-toned dusty rose. It’s one of the most universally flattering shades in the line, adding just the right hint of fresh, pretty color to any skin tone.
-
Red Velvet: The Bold Statement. A vibrant, blue-toned red that packs a punch. It’s creamy, opaque, and gives a high-impact glossy red lip without the high-end price tag.
Pro Tips: How to Apply & Wear It Like a Makeup Artist
To get the most out of your Butter Gloss, follow these simple tips:
-
Prep is Key: For a smooth application, gently exfoliate your lips with a damp washcloth and apply a light balm 5 minutes before gloss. Blot off any excess balm.
-
Layer for Dimension: Don’t be afraid to layer! Apply a liner in a similar shade first for longer wear and sharper definition. You can also dab the gloss just in the center of your lips over matte lipstick for a fuller, 3D effect.
-
The Blotted Lip Trick: For a modern, stained look, apply a generous amount, let it settle for 30 seconds, then gently blot with a tissue. This leaves a beautiful, even wash of color with a subtle sheen.
Final Verdict & Who It’s For
The Bottom Line: NYX Butter Gloss absolutely deserves its holy-grail status in the drugstore aisle. It delivers exceptional shine, comfort, and color variety for an unbeatable price.
It’s perfect for you if: You love a glossy lip but hate sticky textures. You’re looking for an affordable way to build a shade collection. You want a low-maintenance, comfortable lip product for daily wear.
You might skip it if: You need extreme, all-day longevity without touch-ups. Also, you strongly prefer completely unscented makeup.
What’s your favorite NYX Butter Gloss shade, or which one are you excited to try? Swatch them and share your thoughts with our community in the comments below!